Peanut Butter Cups
We make oversized peanut butter cups in our own shop — from the 4-inch Big Cup ($6.99) up to the Colossal, a 10-inch cup that weighs almost four pounds ($38.99). What makes ours different is crushed graham crackers folded into the peanut butter filling, which gives it a texture closer to a candy bar than a supermarket cup.
Most sizes come in milk, dark or white chocolate at the same price, and the Custom Cup lets you pick your own mix-ins.
Filter and sort
Every size, compared
The main question people have is which size to buy. Here's the whole lineup with real dimensions and weights.
| Cup | Diameter | Height | Weight | Price | Serves |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Colossal | 10" | 1" | Almost 4 lbs | $38.99 | ~20–30, sliced |
| Giant | 7.75" | 1" | Over 2 lbs | $27.99 | ~12–16, sliced |
| Custom Cup | 6" | Over 1.5" | ~1.5 lbs | $35.99 | ~8–12, sliced |
| Big Cup | ~4" | ½" | ~5–6 oz | $6.99 | 1–2 |
The Colossal and Giant both ship in a pizza box, which is exactly as satisfying to open as it sounds. Serving estimates above assume you're cutting them into wedges like a cake — which is genuinely how most customers use them.
Choosing a flavor
The Colossal, Giant and Custom cups all offer milk, dark or white chocolate at the same price. The 4-inch Big Cup is where the flavor experimenting happens, all at $6.99:
- Milk Chocolate, Dark Chocolate and White Chocolate — the classics
- Fluffernutter — marshmallow fluff, our top-selling Big Cup flavor
- Peanut Butter Lover's — peanut butter coating on peanut butter filling
- Nutter Butter, Cookies and Cream, and Cookie Dough
- Potato Chip & Pretzel — for the sweet-and-salty crowd
Not sure? The Big Peanut Butter Cup Sampler ($36.99) is six Big Cups: one milk, one white, one dark, plus three chosen by us from the specialty flavors.
The Custom Cup
The Custom Peanut Butter Cup ($35.99) is our single best-selling item in this collection. You pick your chocolate, then choose up to three mix-ins for our peanut butter cuppers to fold into the filling — and we put some on top too, so it looks like what's inside.
Also in this collection
Not everything here is oversized. If you want normal-sized cups in bulk:
- Milk Chocolate Mini Peanut Butter Cups — Gertrude Hawk, $11.49 per pound (certified Dairy)
- Dark Chocolate Mini Peanut Butter Cups — Gertrude Hawk, $10.49 per pound (certified Dairy)
- Sugar Free Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups — 8 oz, $11.49 (certified Dairy). See more sugar free candy.
- Peanut Butter Cup Popcorn — the flavor, applied to popcorn, from $6.99
Ingredients and allergens
Our house cups are built from peanut butter (peanuts, dextrose, hydrogenated vegetable oil, salt), a chocolate coating, and crushed graham crackers — which means they contain peanuts and wheat. Most also carry the statement "produced in a facility that processes dairy, soy and nuts." The Fluffernutter additionally contains egg, from the marshmallow fluff.
Full ingredient statements are on every product page. These are not suitable for anyone with a peanut, wheat or tree nut allergy.
Shipping in warm weather
Chocolate and summer heat don't mix. If you're ordering between late spring and early fall, or shipping somewhere hot, add ice packs ($2.00) to your order. They're the cheapest insurance available against a cup arriving as a puddle.
Frequently asked questions
How big is the Colossal peanut butter cup?
Ten inches across, one inch thick, and it weighs almost four pounds. It ships in a pizza box. At $38.99 it works out to under $10 a pound, which for a novelty item that doubles as a birthday cake is a reasonable deal.
Can a giant peanut butter cup replace a birthday cake?
Plenty of our customers do exactly that. Slice the Colossal or Giant into wedges like a pie — the Colossal serves roughly 20 to 30 people that way, the Giant about 12 to 16. It's easier than a cake, needs no refrigeration in a cool room, and nobody has to pretend to like fondant.
What's actually inside your peanut butter cups?
Peanut butter filling with crushed graham crackers mixed in, coated in milk, dark or white chocolate. The graham cracker is the part that makes ours taste different from a standard mass-market cup — it adds a bit of structure and a toasted note.
Do you make dark chocolate and white chocolate versions?
Yes. Milk, dark and white are all available on the Colossal, Giant and Custom cups at no price difference, and as individual Big Cups.
Are your peanut butter cups kosher?
The Gertrude Hawk mini cups and the sugar free mini cups are certified Dairy. Our house-made cups do not carry a kosher certification. For certified options, browse kosher candy or kosher dairy.
How long do they keep?
Store in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Like any chocolate product, they're best within a few weeks and should not be left in a hot car or a sunny windowsill.
Go big
Start with the Custom Cup if you want it your way, the Colossal if you want the reaction, or the Sampler if you just want to work out which flavor is yours.