Quick view NEW Atkinson's Sophie Mae Peanut Brittle - 4 oz $3.29 Sophie Mae Handmade Peanut Brittle 1 Inch Peanut Bites Approx. 18 Bites per Box 4 oz Box 5 Ingredients Gluten Free Vegan Friendly Cholesterol Free Zero Trans Fats Kosher Made in the... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Mint Twists Giant Peppermint Stick - 2 lb $13.49 Mint Twists Giant Peppermint Stick Infused With Natural Peppermint Oil Red, White, and Green Striped Approx. Length is 13 Inches 2 lb Stick Kosher The Mint Twists Giant Peppermint Stick is a 2 lb... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Mint Twists Giant Peppermint Stick - 3.5 oz $1.59 Mint Twists Giant Wrapped Peppermint Stick Classic Red and White Striped Approx. 10 in. 3.5 oz Stick Kosher Mint Twists Giant Peppermint Stick offers a delightful combination of a classic red and... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Rainbow Sticks - Wild Cherry - 36 Count Box $13.99 Rainbow Stick Individually Wrapped Wild Cherry Flavor Rainbow Swirl Each Stick Approx. 5.5 inches in length 0.7 oz Candy Stick 36 Sticks Per Box 1 lb, 9.4 oz Box Made in a Peanut-Free, Allergen-Free... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Jumbo Mint Sticks - 36 Count Box $13.99 Jumbo Mint Sticks Individually Wrapped Cooling Peppermint Flavor Red and White Classic Swirl Each Stick Approx. 5.5 inches in length 0.7 oz Candy Stick 36 Sticks Per Box 1 lb, 9.4 oz Box Made in a... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Chick-O-Stick - 0.7 oz $0.79 Chick-O-Stick 0.7 oz Stick Available per Stick or in 36 Count Crunchy Peanut Butter Rolled in Toasted Coconut Kosher Certified Vegan Gluten Free Made in USA We're cheering for Chick-O-Sticks! This... Choose Options Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Mary Janes - Fun Size - 2 lb Bag $15.49 Mary Janes - Fun Size Chewy Taffy Peanut Butter Flavored Individually Wrapped Old Fashioned Favorite 2 lb Bag Approx. 104 Mary Janes per bag Kosher Dairy Made in USA Mary Janes are chewy... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Mary Janes Tubs - 160 Ct $18.99 Mary Janes Chewy Molasses and Peanut Butter Candy Old Fashioned Favorite 160 Ct Tub Kosher Certified - Dairy Made in USA They're Back, you can't keep a good thing down. NECCO is gone but Atkinson... Out of Stock Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Mary Jane - 3 oz $2.49 Mary Jane Taffy Candy Molasses and Peanut Butter Flavor Individually Wrapped 3 oz bag A nostalgic candy favorite, Mary Janes have been around for almost 100 years, because candy makers know... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Chick-O-Sticks - 2.5 lb $18.49 New Formulation: All Natural Colors Crunchy Peanut Butter Candy Peanut Butter Flavor Individually wrapped 2.5 lb Bag Approx. 160 pieces per Bag Gluten free Kosher - Pareve Made in the U.S... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Coconut Long Boys - 2.5 lb Per Bag $18.99 Hard candies Brown candy, yellow wrapper Caramel and coconut flavor Each is about 3.25 inches long Individually wrapped Gluten free Kosher - Dairy Made in the U.S. 2.5 Lb Bag Approximately 115... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Chick-O-Sticks - 24 Count $34.99 Chick-O-Stick Bars Individually Wrapped Approximately 8 inches in length 24 Count Box Peanut Butter Candy rolled in Toasted Coconut Kosher Certified Made in the USA Chick-O-Stick bars feature... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Chick-O-Stick Nuggets - 2.5 lb Bag $15.99 Chick O Stick Nuggets Crunchy Peanut Butter Candy Peanut Butter Flavor Individually wrapped 2.5 lb Bag Approx. 160 pieces per Bag Gluten free Kosher - Pareve Made in the U.S. Chick-o-Sticks are a... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Mary Janes - 2.5 lb Bag $19.49 Mary Janes Individually Wrapped Chewy Molasses and Peanut Butter Candy Old Fashioned Favorite 2.5 lb Bag Approximately 125 pieces per Bag Kosher Certified Kosher Dairy Made in USA They're Back,... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars $3.99 Rectangular hard candies Cream colored Peanut butter flavor Sugar free Each is about 0.75" x 1.5" x 0.25" Individually wrapped Gluten free Kosher - Pareve Made in the U.S. 3.75-ounce bag... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Sugar Free Chick-O-Sticks Nuggets - 3.75 oz Bag $3.99 Nugget-shaped hard candies Dark orange color Peanut butter and toasted coconut flavor Each is about 1.25 inches long Individually wrapped Kosher - Pareve Made in the U.S. 3.75 ounce bag... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
Quick view Atkinson's Peanut Butter Bars - 2.5 lb $12.49 Peanut Butter Bars Cream colored Peanut butter flavor Each is about 0.75" x 1.5" x 0.25" Individually wrapped Gluten free Kosher - Pareve Made in the U.S. 2.5-pound bag Approximately 160 pieces per... Add to Cart Add to Wish list Compare
